Patent·Score 10

Wildanger and AsusTek Win FRAND Defense in UPC Dispute Against Ericsson

The UPC Milan local division revoked one Ericsson patent (EP 3 076 673) and, despite finding indirect infringement of another (EP 2 727 342), refused to issue an injunction against AsusTek due to a successful FRAND defense under Huawei v. ZTE framework.

WISECODE Take

Hardware manufacturers facing standard-essential patent (SEP) litigation often mistakenly believe their only choices are accepting exorbitant royalty terms or suffering market injunctions. The Milan local division of the Unified Patent Court (UPC) shattered this myth in cases including UPC_CFI_318/2024. The court revoked Ericsson's EP 3 076 673 patent. Regarding EP 2 727 342, although finding AsusTek indirectly infringed, the panel accepted AsusTek's FRAND defense under the CJEU Huawei v. ZTE framework and refused to grant an injunction. Much like a defender making a legal play to avoid a flagrant foul call, implementers of the HEVC/H.265 standard can neutralize injunction threats by maintaining a compliant negotiation record. Knowledge & Wisdom provides patent portfolio health checks to help enterprises construct such negotiation evidence. Companies facing SEP claims should take two concrete actions. First, respond promptly according to the Huawei v. ZTE timeline to demonstrate willingness to license while requesting justification for royalty rates. Second, launch simultaneous invalidation challenges against asserted patents, targeting added matter and lack of novelty. A documented, compliant negotiation record remains the most effective defense against SEP-based injunctions.

Original sources

Compiled automatically by WISECODE IP Radar. Summaries are short source excerpts; commentary is AI-generated. See the source links for full text.

How does this affect your company?

WISECODE assesses IP risk and helps you decide what the news means for your next step.

Ask WISECODE

← Back to IP Radar