In case UPC_CFI_318/2024, the UPC Milan Local Division concluded the patent litigation between Ericsson and AsusTek. Presiding Judge Pierluigi Perrotti revoked Ericsson's EP 3 076 673 patent. For EP 2 727 342, although the court found AsusTek liable for indirect infringement, it rejected Ericsson's request for an injunction because AsusTek complied with FRAND principles under the EU Huawei v. ZTE framework.
Enterprises often assume that standard-essential patent (SEP) infringement inevitably leads to excessive royalties or product bans. This ruling demonstrates that implementers who maintain compliant negotiation records can effectively block injunctions. Parties unaffected by this decision include non-SEP implementers and unwilling licensees who ignore licensing offers or withhold financial data, as bad-faith delay tactics still invite injunction risks.
Legal heads receiving SEP warning letters should respond within two weeks following the Huawei v. ZTE timeline to express licensing willingness and request calculation details, documenting all communications. Simultaneously, R&D and patent teams should file invalidation actions against asserted patents, targeting claim over-amendments and novelty defects.